Talk:Avispa Fukuoka

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Is this section good for the article?[change source]

Does this list help make the article better? I don't think it does.

If there is consensus for including this information, the section can be restored at any time. --Horeki (talk) 17:15, 6 March 2012 (UTC)


In 2010,<:ref>, "Avispa Fukuoka"; retrieved 2012-3-6.</ref> the team included Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules. Players may hold more than one non-FIFA nationality.

No. Position Player
1 Japan GK Ryuichi Kamiyama
2 Japan DF Kazuki Yamaguchi
3 Japan DF Tatsunori Yamagata
4 Japan MF Shu Abe
5 Japan DF Makoto Tanaka
6 Japan DF Daiki Niwa
7 Japan MF Kiyokazu Kudo
8 Japan MF Jun Suzuki
9 Japan FW Yutaka Takahashi
10 Japan MF Hisashi Jogo
11 Japan FW Yusuke Tanaka
13 Japan DF Tomokazu Nagira
14 Japan MF Genki Nagasato
15 Japan MF Kosuke Nakamachi
16 Japan FW Hideya Okamoto
17 Japan DF Takanori Nakajima
18 Japan FW Masato Yoshihara
19 Japan FW Tetsuya Okubo
20 Japan DF Yosuke Miyaji
No. Position Player
21 Japan FW Kyohei Oyama
22 Japan MF Toshiya Sueyoshi
23 Japan GK Yuji Rokutan
24 Japan DF Kenta Hiraishi
25 Japan GK Eita Kasagawa
26 North Korea DF Son Jeong-Ryun

Comment[change source]

Creol explains at Talk:Sanfrecce Hiroshima: "Most football team articles include the team list ... but these lists require constant upkeep that may not be worth the effort for a smaller wiki."

It's true it would become quickly outdated, but as long as you have the year in there and it's past tense, I don't see that it would particularly harmful. It's like reading a 2010 lineup booklet. Osiris (talk) 14:19, 7 March 2012 (UTC)
Osiris -- As context, we can see that a format similar to en:Avispa Fukuoka is mirrored. However, several wikis have no table of players.
No table
Table with red links
This is also part of a larger picture.

For example, please consider the mass of cut-and-paste articles which are discussed at User talk:Nameless User and User talk:Japan Football?

Osiris, how can we develop structural responses to problems which are likely in the future?

Is this one plausible step in a process? --Horeki (talk) 16:29, 8 March 2012 (UTC)