Talk:Avispa Fukuoka

This article contains a translation of Avispa Fukuoka from en.wikipedia.

Is this section good for the article?[change source]

Does this list help make the article better? I don't think it does.

If there is consensus for including this information, the section can be restored at any time. --Horeki (talk) 17:15, 6 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Players

In 2010,<:ref>Soccerway.com, "Avispa Fukuoka"; retrieved 2012-3-6.</ref> the team included Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules. Players may hold more than one non-FIFA nationality.


No.	Pos.	Nation	Player
1	GK	Japan	Ryuichi Kamiyama
2	DF	Japan	Kazuki Yamaguchi
3	DF	Japan	Tatsunori Yamagata
4	MF	Japan	Shu Abe
5	DF	Japan	Makoto Tanaka
6	DF	Japan	Daiki Niwa
7	MF	Japan	Kiyokazu Kudo
8	MF	Japan	Jun Suzuki
9	FW	Japan	Yutaka Takahashi
10	MF	Japan	Hisashi Jogo
11	FW	Japan	Yusuke Tanaka
13	DF	Japan	Tomokazu Nagira
14	MF	Japan	Genki Nagasato
15	MF	Japan	Kosuke Nakamachi
16	FW	Japan	Hideya Okamoto
17	DF	Japan	Takanori Nakajima
18	FW	Japan	Masato Yoshihara
19	FW	Japan	Tetsuya Okubo
20	DF	Japan	Yosuke Miyaji


No.	Pos.	Nation	Player
21	FW	Japan	Kyohei Oyama
22	MF	Japan	Toshiya Sueyoshi
23	GK	Japan	Yuji Rokutan
24	DF	Japan	Kenta Hiraishi
25	GK	Japan	Eita Kasagawa
26	DF	North Korea	Son Jeong-Ryun

Comment[change source]

Creol explains at Talk:Sanfrecce Hiroshima: "Most football team articles include the team list ... but these lists require constant upkeep that may not be worth the effort for a smaller wiki."

It's true it would become quickly outdated, but as long as you have the year in there and it's past tense, I don't see that it would particularly harmful. It's like reading a 2010 lineup booklet. Osiris (talk) 14:19, 7 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Osiris -- As context, we can see that a format similar to en:Avispa Fukuoka is mirrored. However, several wikis have no table of players.

No table

Table with red links

This is also part of a larger picture.

For example, please consider the mass of cut-and-paste articles which are discussed at User talk:Nameless User and User talk:Japan Football?

Osiris, how can we develop structural responses to problems which are likely in the future?

Is this one plausible step in a process? --Horeki (talk) 16:29, 8 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]