Talk:Kamariya Ahir (Yadav)

Request for Consensus on the Kamariya Ahir (Yadav) Article

Hello everyone,

I am initiating this discussion to seek consensus on improving the Kamariya Ahir (Yadav) article. Previously, I have noticed instances of vandalism on the page, as well as challenges regarding the removal of certain content. Some editors and admins have raised concerns about the validity of the sources cited, stating that they are either passing or mere mentions rather than detailed descriptions.

While I acknowledge the importance of high-quality sourcing, I believe that multiple passing mentions, when considered collectively, can provide substantial evidence for the inclusion of specific information. Furthermore, the article also includes detailed references that support its content.

Moreover, I have observed instances of personal attacks directed toward users and the article itself, which detract from a constructive editing environment. This may stem from misunderstandings, biases, or other motives, but I hope this discussion will allow us to address these issues collaboratively and professionally.

I invite all editors, including (for example, @ChrisWx, @BRPever, and others), to provide their input, suggestions, and thoughts on how we can improve this page while adhering to Wikipedia’s guidelines. To ensure accuracy and neutrality, I would also kindly request editors to:

• Visit the article and review all sources, citations, and references.

• Verify whether the cited sources are accurately representing the content written in the article.

• Check if there are any discrepancies between what the article says and what the sources state.

• Identify which sources are passing mentions and which are detailed references.

Once the article is thoroughly improved, finalized, and deemed neutral, comprehensive, and reliable, I request that the page be logged for protection to prevent future vandalism. Additionally, since I am the one who expanded the article from almost nothing to its current detailed state with well-sourced content, I would like to request administrator rights for this page. This would allow me to make necessary updates or improvements in the future while ensuring the page remains protected.

As a new editor on Wikipedia, I would also greatly appreciate guidance on how to navigate and contribute effectively to the platform. I’m eager to learn and understand how to collaborate better with the community to maintain high-quality articles.

Thank you, and I look forward to hearing your perspectives, feedback, and advice. Let’s work together to enhance and stabilize this article!

— Nlkyair012 (talk) 13:22, 10 December 2024 (UTC)

I wanted to bring to your attention that earlier today (10th December 2024), an IP editor vandalised the Kamaria Ahir (Yadav) article by redirecting it to the Muslim Ghosi page. This action does not contribute to the improvement or stability of the article but instead undermines the ongoing collaborative efforts.@ChrisWx

The IP address involved in this activity and his version is as follows:

• @2409:40D0:5:58D3:1410:1644:2960:4F8E and the vandalised version made by them-here, and here

It is clear that such edits are not aimed at improving, updating, or stabilizing the page but are instead personal attacks targeting the article’s topic and details. I would like to request that appropriate action be taken against such behavior to ensure that the discussion and editing environment remain constructive by either blacklisting such peoples Ip or protecting the page whichever you all think is the best. @MathXplore I’d request your kind actions here.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. Let’s continue working together to improve this article and keep it protected from disruptive actions.

Best regards,

— Nlkyair012 (talk) 08:11, 11 December 2024 (UTC)

I agree with Nlkyair012 there are been lot of destructive edits on this page some solution is surely needed for this. Mr.Hanes Talk 19:49, 11 December 2024 (UTC)

update: Page Semi-Protected for One Month

Hello everyone,

I’d like to inform you all that @Auntof6 has kindly applied semi-protection to the Kamariya Ahir (Yadav) page for one month(Till 11 January 2025) and only Autoconfirmed Users This protection will help safeguard the article from random IP edits and potential vandalism while we work together to improve and stabilize it.

During this time, we have the opportunity to focus on enhancing the article and ensuring it becomes as accurate, comprehensive, and neutral as possible. If any IP editors have concerns, suggestions, or edits they would like to propose, I encourage them to share their input here in the Talk page. This way, we can address their issues collaboratively and make decisions by consensus.

Let’s use this protected period productively to refine the article and ensure it reaches a stable, high-quality version that represents the subject fairly and accurately. Thank you all for your ongoing contributions and efforts!

Best regards,

- Nlkyair012 (talk) 12:31, 11 December 2024 (UTC)